Does Illinois Cap Pain Awards in a Birth Injury Case?

A birth injury in a Chicago hospital raises a question you may still hear from friends: is there a dollar cap on pain, disfigurement, or the loss of a normal life? In Illinois, the short answer is no, not under current law. The Illinois Supreme Court struck the last statutory cap on February 4, 2010. The opinion in Abigaile Lebron’s suit against Gottlieb Memorial Hospital, reported at 237 Ill. 2d 217, 930 N.E.2d 895 (2010), is controlling.

The case involved Abigaile Lebron, then a child, who sued with her mother, Frances Lebron. The complaint alleged that after a Caesarean delivery at Gottlieb Memorial Hospital on October 31, 2005, Abigaile was left with a severe brain injury and cerebral palsy, along with cognitive harm and the use of a feeding tube. The family also sought a declaration that the 2005 damages cap could not stand.

What did the 2005 cap try to do?

Public Act 94-677, which took effect on August 25, 2005, added section 2-1706.5 to the Code of Civil Procedure. In a medical malpractice case, or a wrongful-death case based on medical malpractice, hospital-side noneconomic awards were limited to $1 million for all plaintiffs arising out of the care, and physician-side awards were limited to $500,000. The jury was not supposed to be told that those limits existed.

Economic losses, such as future medical care and lost earnings, were not limited by that section. The fight was about pain, disfigurement, and similar noneconomic harm. If you are assembling a Chicago birth-injury file, take that cap question, and the filing rules that remain, to Chicago birth injury attorneys at Shore Injury Law.

Why the Supreme Court struck it down

The justices held that the ceiling functioned as a legislative remittitur. It required a trial court to cut a jury’s noneconomic award down to a preset figure, without looking at the facts of the case and without the plaintiff’s consent. The Court relied on Best v. Taylor Machine Works, a 1997 Illinois Supreme Court decision published at 179 Ill. 2d 367. It said that kind of automatic cut invades the judiciary’s role in deciding whether a particular verdict is excessive.

Because the 2005 Act included an inseverability clause, the Court held the entire Act void. Other provisions fell with the cap, but only because they were tied to it. The Court noted that the legislature remained free to reenact standalone provisions if it chose to.

The certificate you still have to file

Striking the cap did not remove the certificate-of-merit rule you still face under Illinois statute 735 ILCS 5/2-622. Your healing-art malpractice complaint still has to be accompanied by an affidavit. In the usual path, the affidavit recites that a properly credentialed clinician examined the records, prepared a written report, and concluded the claim has a sound, meritorious footing. For most physician and hospital defendants, that report has to come from a fully licensed physician.

The reviewing professional must have recent practice or teaching experience in that same field, covering the prior six years. The written report goes on the affidavit as an attachment, though the reviewer’s name may be removed. A separate certificate and report are required for each defendant. If a limitations deadline is about to expire, the certificate and report may follow within 90 days of the filing. Dismissal under section 2-619 is the statutory consequence of a missing certificate.

How long does a child have?

Section 13-212(b), current through Public Act 103-478 (effective January 1, 2024), gives a special period when the injured person was under 18 at accrual. The lawsuit must be started within eight years of the act or the omission, and no filing is allowed once the person has turned 22. For an injury at birth, the eight-year mark arrives long before age 22, so that period is usually the one that matters for your child’s claim.

Section 13-212(a) still uses a two-year discovery period and a four-year outer period. Subsection (c) delays the start of the period if a different legal disability exists at accrual. As of November 11, 2026, a search of later Illinois legislation did not turn up a new, valid noneconomic cap.

Planning for long-term costs

If your child has lasting injuries, you also face years of therapy, equipment, and care costs. Tips for saving money when you have a special needs child are a household problem beside your legal file. Illinois does not currently cut a jury’s noneconomic award down to a statutory ceiling.

If you are reviewing a Chicago delivery, gather your prenatal, labor, and neonatal records early. Calendar your eight-year mark in section 13-212(b) from the delivery date. Talk with counsel about your section 2-622 report before filing.